WikiToon aims to document notable topics related to cartoons, comics, animation, and caricature art. To ensure content quality, all articles must meet specific notability standards. This guideline helps determine whether a subject is significant enough for inclusion.
1. General Notability Guidelines
A subject is considered notable if it has received significant coverage from reliable, independent sources. Articles must be based on verifiable information rather than personal opinions or self-published materials.
To qualify for a standalone article, a topic must meet at least one of the following criteria:
- It has been covered by multiple independent sources (e.g., books, newspapers, magazines, academic journals).
- It has received critical recognition or awards from reputable institutions.
- It has played a significant role in the history, culture, or evolution of cartoons, comics, or animation.
2. Notability Criteria for Different Topics
a) Cartoonists and Illustrators
A cartoonist, comic artist, or illustrator is considered notable if they meet one or more of the following:
- They have published work in major publications (e.g., newspapers, comic books, animation studios).
- Their work has been the subject of independent reviews, interviews, or academic studies.
- They have won prestigious awards (e.g., Eisner Award, Harvey Award, Stripschapprijs).
- Their artistic contributions have had a lasting impact on the industry or public discourse.
b) Comic Strips, Books, and Graphic Novels
A comic or graphic novel is considered notable if:
- It has been published by a recognized publisher (not self-published unless widely covered).
- It has received significant media coverage or academic analysis.
- It has influenced popular culture or the comic industry.
- It has been adapted into films, TV shows, or other media.
c) Animated Films and TV Series
An animated film or series is notable if:
- It has been produced or distributed by a recognized studio (e.g., Disney, Warner Bros., Studio Ghibli).
- It has received major awards (e.g., Academy Award, Annie Award).
- It has had significant cultural, historical, or critical impact.
- It has been widely discussed in credible reviews or academic studies.
d) Editorial and Political Cartoons
A political or editorial cartoon is notable if:
- It has been published in a recognized newspaper or magazine with broad readership.
- It has sparked public discourse, controversy, or legal discussions.
- It has been created by a notable cartoonist with established credentials.
e) Comic Conventions and Industry Events
An event related to comics and animation is notable if:
- It has been held multiple times and received media coverage.
- It is attended by well-known industry professionals or has influenced the industry.
- It has been featured in news articles, academic papers, or documentary films.
3. Sources and Verifiability
Articles must cite at least two reliable, independent sources, such as:
- Books published by academic or established presses.
- Articles from major newspapers, magazines, or scholarly journals.
- Interviews conducted by reputable media outlets.
Unacceptable sources include:
- Personal websites, blogs, or self-published content.
- Social media posts without verification.
- Fan sites or promotional materials.
4. Merging or Redirecting Non-Notable Topics
If a subject does not meet the notability criteria:
- It may be merged into a broader article (e.g., an artist’s work into their biography).
- It may be redirected to a relevant, more notable topic.
- Articles with no significant sources may be proposed for deletion.
5. Requesting a Notability Review
If an article’s notability is questioned:
- Discuss it on the article’s Talk Page.
- Provide additional sources to support its inclusion.
- If necessary, request a review from WikiToon:Administrators.
6. Related Policies
Following these notability guidelines ensures that WikiToon remains a high-quality and reliable resource. Thank you for your contributions! 🚀