More actions
Created page with "WikiToon aims to document notable topics related to cartoons, comics, animation, and caricature art. To ensure content quality, all articles must meet specific notability standards. This guideline helps determine whether a subject is significant enough for inclusion. == 1. General Notability Guidelines == A subject is considered notable if it has received '''significant coverage''' from '''reliable, independent sources'''. Articles must be based on verifiable informati..." |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
WikiToon aims to document notable topics related to cartoons, comics, animation, and caricature art. To ensure content quality, all articles must meet specific notability standards. This guideline helps determine whether a subject is significant enough for inclusion. | WikiToon aims to document notable topics related to [[Cartoon|cartoons]], [[Comics|comics]], [[Animation|animation]], and [[Caricature|caricature]] art. To ensure content quality, all articles must meet specific notability standards. This guideline helps determine whether a subject is significant enough for inclusion. | ||
== 1. General Notability Guidelines == | == 1. General Notability Guidelines == | ||
Revision as of 22:53, 25 March 2025
WikiToon aims to document notable topics related to cartoons, comics, animation, and caricature art. To ensure content quality, all articles must meet specific notability standards. This guideline helps determine whether a subject is significant enough for inclusion.
1. General Notability Guidelines
A subject is considered notable if it has received significant coverage from reliable, independent sources. Articles must be based on verifiable information rather than personal opinions or self-published materials.
To qualify for a standalone article, a topic must meet at least one of the following criteria:
- It has been covered by multiple independent sources (e.g., books, newspapers, magazines, academic journals).
- It has received critical recognition or awards from reputable institutions.
- It has played a significant role in the history, culture, or evolution of cartoons, comics, or animation.
2. Notability Criteria for Different Topics
a) Cartoonists and Illustrators
A cartoonist, comic artist, or illustrator is considered notable if they meet one or more of the following:
- They have published work in major publications (e.g., newspapers, comic books, animation studios).
- Their work has been the subject of independent reviews, interviews, or academic studies.
- They have won prestigious awards (e.g., Eisner Award, Harvey Award, Stripschapprijs).
- Their artistic contributions have had a lasting impact on the industry or public discourse.
b) Comic Strips, Books, and Graphic Novels
A comic or graphic novel is considered notable if:
- It has been published by a recognized publisher (not self-published unless widely covered).
- It has received significant media coverage or academic analysis.
- It has influenced popular culture or the comic industry.
- It has been adapted into films, TV shows, or other media.
c) Animated Films and TV Series
An animated film or series is notable if:
- It has been produced or distributed by a recognized studio (e.g., Disney, Warner Bros., Studio Ghibli).
- It has received major awards (e.g., Academy Award, Annie Award).
- It has had significant cultural, historical, or critical impact.
- It has been widely discussed in credible reviews or academic studies.
d) Editorial and Political Cartoons
A political or editorial cartoon is notable if:
- It has been published in a recognized newspaper or magazine with broad readership.
- It has sparked public discourse, controversy, or legal discussions.
- It has been created by a notable cartoonist with established credentials.
e) Comic Conventions and Industry Events
An event related to comics and animation is notable if:
- It has been held multiple times and received media coverage.
- It is attended by well-known industry professionals or has influenced the industry.
- It has been featured in news articles, academic papers, or documentary films.
3. Sources and Verifiability
Articles must cite at least two reliable, independent sources, such as:
- Books published by academic or established presses.
- Articles from major newspapers, magazines, or scholarly journals.
- Interviews conducted by reputable media outlets.
Unacceptable sources include:
- Personal websites, blogs, or self-published content.
- Social media posts without verification.
- Fan sites or promotional materials.
4. Merging or Redirecting Non-Notable Topics
If a subject does not meet the notability criteria:
- It may be merged into a broader article (e.g., an artist’s work into their biography).
- It may be redirected to a relevant, more notable topic.
- Articles with no significant sources may be proposed for deletion.
5. Requesting a Notability Review
If an article’s notability is questioned:
- Discuss it on the article’s Talk Page.
- Provide additional sources to support its inclusion.
- If necessary, request a review from WikiToon:Administrators.
6. Related Policies
Following these notability guidelines ensures that WikiToon remains a high-quality and reliable resource. Thank you for your contributions! 🚀